One thing that bothers me about numerous contemporary holiday movies is their excessive meta-commentary – the over-the-top decorations, the predictable music selections, and the clichéd dialogue about the real spirit of the holidays. Maybe because the style hadn't yet hardened into tradition, movies from the 1940s often explore Yuletide from more imaginative and less obsessive viewpoints.
The Fifth Avenue Happening
A delightful gem from sifting through 1940s Christmas fare is It Happened on Fifth Avenue, a 1947 lighthearted comedy with a brilliant concept: a happy-go-lucky vagrant takes up residence in a empty luxurious estate each year. During one cold spell, he brings in strangers to stay with him, including a ex-soldier and a runaway who is secretly the heiress of the property's wealthy proprietor. Helmer Roy Del Ruth infuses the movie with a makeshift family warmth that many modern Christmas movies struggle to attain. This story perfectly walks the line between a class-conscious story on affordable living and a charming metropolitan fantasy.
The Tokyo Godfathers
The late filmmaker's 2003 tragicomedy Tokyo Godfathers is a fun, poignant, and profound version on the festive tale. Inspired by a western movie, it centers on a trio of homeless individuals – an drinker, a trans character, and a adolescent throwaway – who find an abandoned newborn on a snowy December night. Their quest to find the infant's family unleashes a chain of unexpected events involving crime lords, foreigners, and apparently fateful connections. The movie celebrates the magic of chance frequently found in holiday stories, offering it with a cool-toned animation that steers clear of overly sweet emotion.
Introducing John Doe
Although Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life justifiably receives plenty of acclaim, his earlier work Meet John Doe is a compelling holiday story in its own right. Featuring Gary Cooper as a charismatic "forgotten man" and Barbara Stanwyck as a clever journalist, the story starts with a fabricated missive from a man threatening to jump from a ledge on December 24th in frustration. The people's reaction forces the reporter to find a man to play the invented "John Doe," who later becomes a country-wide figure for kindness. The narrative functions as both an uplifting tale and a sharp skewering of wealthy media magnates trying to exploit popular feeling for personal ambitions.
A Silent Partner
While seasonal slasher films are now commonplace, the holiday crime caper remains a relatively underpopulated subgenre. This makes the 1978 film The Silent Partner a unique delight. Featuring a superbly sinister Christopher Plummer as a bank-robbing Santa Claus and Elliott Gould as a clever bank teller, the story pits two varieties of amoral characters against each other in a stylish and unpredictable narrative. Largely overlooked upon its initial release, it is worthy of new attention for those who prefer their festive films with a chilling atmosphere.
The Almost Christmas
For those who like their family gatherings dysfunctional, Almost Christmas is a hoot. With a stellar group that features Danny Glover, Mo'Nique, and JB Smoove, the story delves into the tensions of a clan gathered to endure five days under one home during the Christmas season. Secret issues rise to the top, culminating in moments of over-the-top farce, including a confrontation where a shotgun is brandished. Ultimately, the film reaches a touching resolution, providing all the enjoyment of a seasonal disaster without any of the actual cleanup.
Go
Doug Liman's 1999 film Go is a Yuletide-adjacent tale that serves as a teen-oriented interpretation on interconnected narratives. While some of its edginess may feel dated upon a modern viewing, the movie nevertheless contains several aspects to savor. These are a engaging turn from Sarah Polley to a captivating scene by Timothy Olyphant as a laid-back pusher who fittingly wears a Santa hat. It captures a particular kind of late-90s film attitude set against a Christmas setting.
Morgan's Creek Miracle
Preston Sturges's wartime comedy The Miracle of Morgan's Creek skips conventional Christmas warmth in return for irreverent humor. The story is about Betty Hutton's character, who finds herself pregnant after a drunken night but cannot recall the father responsible. Much of the fun arises from her condition and the attempts of Eddie Bracken's hapless Norval Jones to marry her. Although not explicitly a holiday film at the beginning, the narrative culminates on the festive day, making clear that Sturges has refashioned a clever interpretation of the Christmas story, loaded with his trademark witty edge.
Better Off Dead Movie
This 1985 teen comedy starring John Cusack, Better Off Dead, is a quintessential specimen of its time. Cusack's